Source: https://fincobra.com/blog/sharesight-yahoo-crypto-pnl.html


# Sharesight and Yahoo vs Crypto PnL

If you are searching for a **portfolio tracker crypto vs stocks**, you are usually deciding one job:

- **equities, dividends, and tax reports** in a stock-first tracker, or
- **current-position crypto PnL** on a short source list, with stocks left in the equity tool

Those are different products. FinCobra Watchlist is a **companion / subset**. It is **not a Sharesight or Yahoo replacement**. It does **not** sync stocks or ETFs.

**Quick answer:** Sharesight and Yahoo win **equities, dividends, and tax reports**. [FinCobra Watchlist](https://watch.fincobra.com/) is a [SPA/PWA](https://watch.fincobra.com/) with [docs](https://watch.fincobra.com/docs/) for **zero-crossing / current-position crypto PnL**. Sign up with **Google or a wallet**. **3 free**, then **$1/mo or $10/yr**. **No tax.** **No stocks/ETFs sync.** **No MCP.** **Not local-only.**

This is a fit filter. They keep the stock book. We do not replace them for stocks.

## The split that actually matters

Sharesight is a **portfolio tracker, not a broker**. Crypto on Sharesight is **file / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers**. There is **no xPub**.

Yahoo official plans are **not a broker-dealer**. Official plans (2026-08-26): **Bronze $95.40/yr**, **Silver $239.40/yr**, **Gold $479.40/yr**, with the yearly toggle at **$7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95**. Yodlee linking is **US-only**.

FinCobra Watchlist is the **crypto PnL** product. You sign in with Google or a wallet. You add Bitcoin xPub; EVM on Ethereum, Arbitrum, and BSC; Solana; Binance or Bybit **read-only API, spot only**; or a Hyperliquid **address**. You type bank, cash, and property by hand. **No Plaid.** PnL is **zero-crossing / current-position**. **Bitcoin xPub** is the strongest full-history source.

If the job is “track my brokerage book and dividends,” stay on Sharesight or Yahoo. Watchlist does **not** sync stocks or ETFs. If the job is “watch those crypto sources and current-position PnL,” Watchlist is the cheaper companion.

## Sharesight, Yahoo, and Watchlist at a glance

| | Sharesight (2026-08-26) | Yahoo official plans (2026-08-26) | FinCobra Watchlist |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Product | Portfolio tracker. **Not a broker.** | Market / portfolio product. **Not a broker-dealer.** | [SPA/PWA](https://watch.fincobra.com/). [Docs](https://watch.fincobra.com/docs/). Crypto companion, not a stock replacement. |
| Signup | Their account flow. | Their account flow. | **Google or wallet.** |
| Stocks / ETFs | That is the product they sell. | That is the product they sell. | **No stocks/ETFs sync.** |
| Crypto | File / CSV / manual **CRYPTO** tickers. **No xPub.** | A stock-first portfolio, not this page’s crypto source list. | **BTC xPub**; **EVM ETH / Arbitrum / BSC**; **Solana**; **Binance + Bybit RO API, spot only**; **Hyperliquid by address.** |
| Bank / cash / property | See their product. Not quoted here. | Yodlee **US-only**. | **Manual** only. **No Plaid.** |
| PnL / reports | Paid plans can include **tax reports**. Free does **not**. | Equities and dividends. | **Zero-crossing / current-position PnL.** **Bitcoin xPub** strongest full-history. **No tax.** |
| Headline price | **Free:** 1 portfolio / 10 holdings. **Starter** $7 USD/mo billed annually ($9.33 monthly). **Standard** $18 / $24. **Premium** $23.25 / $31. **Business** $13.50 per portfolio/month. | **Bronze** $95.40/yr. **Silver** $239.40/yr. **Gold** $479.40/yr. Yearly toggle **$7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95**. | **3 free**, then **$1/mo or $10/yr.** |
| What it is not | Not a broker. | Not a broker-dealer. | **Not a Sharesight or Yahoo replacement.** **No MCP.** **Not local-only.** |
| Best fit | Equities, dividends, tax reports. | Equities and a US-only Yodlee link. | Crypto PnL companion. Not a stock tracker. |

Sharesight prices and the Free tax-report limit are from Sharesight pricing as of 2026-08-26. Yahoo plan dollars are from Yahoo’s official plans as of 2026-08-26. Recheck those products — plans move. This page does not publish a live Sharesight or Yahoo URL.

## Choose Sharesight if

Choose Sharesight if most of these are true:

- You want a **stock-first** portfolio tracker with **dividends** and **tax reports**.
- **Free** (1 portfolio / 10 holdings) is enough to try, and you accept that **Free has no tax reports**.
- You will pay **Starter $7 USD/mo billed annually** ($9.33 monthly), **Standard $18 / $24**, **Premium $23.25 / $31**, or **Business $13.50 per portfolio/month**.
- Crypto, if you add it, can live as **file / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers**. You do not need an xPub.
- You want a tracker, **not a broker**.

If that is the job, use Sharesight. Watchlist will not grow stock sync to win this page.

## Choose Yahoo if

Choose Yahoo if most of these are true:

- You already live in Yahoo’s market / portfolio surface.
- **Bronze $95.40/yr**, **Silver $239.40/yr**, or **Gold $479.40/yr** (yearly toggle **$7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95**) is the price you expected.
- A **Yodlee** link that is **US-only** is enough.
- You want a market product that is **not a broker-dealer**.

If that is the job, use Yahoo. Watchlist is not a Yahoo clone.

## Choose Watchlist if

Choose FinCobra Watchlist if most of these are true:

- You will live on the **shipped crypto sources only**: Bitcoin xPub; EVM on Ethereum, Arbitrum, and BSC; Solana; Binance and Bybit **read-only API, spot only**; Hyperliquid **by address**.
- You want **zero-crossing / current-position PnL**, with **Bitcoin xPub** as the strongest full-history source. Details: [Watchlist docs](https://watch.fincobra.com/docs/).
- You will **enter bank, cash, and property by hand**. **No Plaid.**
- **3 free**, then **$1/mo or $10/yr**, is the price you want.
- You will sign in with **Google or a wallet**, on the [SPA/PWA](https://watch.fincobra.com/). **Not local-only.** **No MCP.**
- You will **keep Sharesight or Yahoo for stocks**. Watchlist does **not** sync stocks or ETFs and does **not** do tax.

“Portfolio tracker crypto vs stocks” here means **companion**. Not “Sharesight with a $10 sticker.”

## Where Sharesight and Yahoo win, without the dodge

**Equities and dividends.** That is their book. Watchlist has **no stocks/ETFs sync**.

**Tax reports.** Sharesight’s **Free** plan has **no tax reports**. Paid Sharesight is the tax-report product on this page. Watchlist has **no tax**.

**Stock-first catalog.** Sharesight and Yahoo are built for brokerages and listed holdings. Watchlist ships the short crypto list above. We will not invent a brokerage sync.

If you need those, stop. Keep Sharesight or Yahoo.

## What Watchlist actually is

Watchlist is the [SPA/PWA](https://watch.fincobra.com/). Sign up with **Google or a wallet**. It is **not local-only**. There is **no MCP**. [Docs](https://watch.fincobra.com/docs/).

Shipped crypto sources:

- Bitcoin xPub
- EVM: Ethereum, Arbitrum, BSC
- Solana
- Binance read-only API, **spot only**
- Bybit read-only API, **spot only**
- Hyperliquid by address

PnL is **zero-crossing / current-position**. **Bitcoin xPub** is the strongest full-history source.

Bank, cash, and property are **manual**. **No Plaid.**

Price: **3 free**, then **$1/mo or $10/yr**.

It is **not a Sharesight or Yahoo replacement**. **No stocks/ETFs sync.** **No tax.**

## Price, honestly

**Sharesight (2026-08-26):** **Free** 1 portfolio / 10 holdings, and Free has **no tax reports**. **Starter** $7 USD/mo billed annually ($9.33 monthly). **Standard** $18 / $24. **Premium** $23.25 / $31. **Business** $13.50 per portfolio/month.

**Yahoo official plans (2026-08-26):** **Bronze** $95.40/yr, **Silver** $239.40/yr, **Gold** $479.40/yr. Yearly toggle **$7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95**.

**Watchlist:** **3 free**, then **$1/mo or $10/yr**.

$10/yr vs Sharesight Starter or Yahoo Bronze is only a comparison if you already accepted **no stock sync** and **no tax**. If you still need equities, dividends, or tax reports, you are comparing a stock tracker to a crypto companion that cannot replace it.

## What crypto-vs-stocks pages usually skip

Most `portfolio tracker crypto vs stocks` results flatten one app into both jobs. That is the wrong set if you still want a brokerage book.

Four skips:

1. **“Watchlist replaces Sharesight or Yahoo.”** It does not. They win equities, dividends, and tax reports. We are a **companion / subset**.
2. **“They both do crypto the same way.”** Sharesight crypto is **file / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers**, **no xPub**. Watchlist sells **zero-crossing / current-position** PnL, with **Bitcoin xPub** as the strongest full-history source.
3. **“$1/mo vs $7 or $7.95.”** True as arithmetic. False as a product comparison unless you already dropped stocks and tax.
4. **A cheaper stock tracker.** Watchlist has **no stocks/ETFs sync**. The price is lower because the job is smaller.

## How to decide in one pass

1. Need **equities, dividends, or tax reports**? → **Sharesight or Yahoo**. Watchlist has **no stocks/ETFs sync** and **no tax**. Stop.
2. Need Sharesight’s **paid tax reports**, or Yahoo’s **US-only Yodlee** link? → **Those products**. Stop.
3. Need a **broker** or **broker-dealer**? → **Neither Sharesight, Yahoo, nor Watchlist.** Stop.
4. Need **zero-crossing / current-position PnL** on the listed crypto sources, **manual** bank/cash/property, **3 free then $1/mo or $10/yr**, while Sharesight or Yahoo keeps the stock book? → **FinCobra Watchlist.**

## Open Watchlist

If step 4 is the job, open [watch.fincobra.com](https://watch.fincobra.com/).

Do not ask us to be Sharesight or Yahoo. They keep stocks. This product tracks crypto PnL.