Sharesight and Yahoo vs Crypto PnL

If you are searching for a portfolio tracker crypto vs stocks, you are usually deciding one job:

• equities, dividends, and tax reports in a stock-first tracker, or
• current-position crypto PnL on a short source list, with stocks left in the equity tool

Those are different products. FinCobra Watchlist is a companion / subset. It is not a Sharesight or Yahoo replacement. It does not sync stocks or ETFs.

Quick answer: Sharesight and Yahoo win equities, dividends, and tax reports. FinCobra Watchlist is a SPA/PWA with docs for zero-crossing / current-position crypto PnL. Sign up with Google or a wallet. 3 free, then $1/mo or $10/yr. No tax. No stocks/ETFs sync. No MCP. Not local-only.

This is a fit filter. They keep the stock book. We do not replace them for stocks.

The split that actually matters

Sharesight is a portfolio tracker, not a broker. Crypto on Sharesight is file / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers. There is no xPub.

Yahoo official plans are not a broker-dealer. Official plans (2026-08-26): Bronze $95.40/yr, Silver $239.40/yr, Gold $479.40/yr, with the yearly toggle at $7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95. Yodlee linking is US-only.

FinCobra Watchlist is the crypto PnL product. You sign in with Google or a wallet. You add Bitcoin xPub; EVM on Ethereum, Arbitrum, and BSC; Solana; Binance or Bybit read-only API, spot only; or a Hyperliquid address. You type bank, cash, and property by hand. No Plaid. PnL is zero-crossing / current-position. Bitcoin xPub is the strongest full-history source.

If the job is “track my brokerage book and dividends,” stay on Sharesight or Yahoo. Watchlist does not sync stocks or ETFs. If the job is “watch those crypto sources and current-position PnL,” Watchlist is the cheaper companion.

Sharesight, Yahoo, and Watchlist at a glance

	Sharesight (2026-08-26)	Yahoo official plans (2026-08-26)	FinCobra Watchlist
Product	Portfolio tracker. Not a broker.	Market / portfolio product. Not a broker-dealer.	SPA/PWA. Docs. Crypto companion, not a stock replacement.
Signup	Their account flow.	Their account flow.	Google or wallet.
Stocks / ETFs	That is the product they sell.	That is the product they sell.	No stocks/ETFs sync.
Crypto	File / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers. No xPub.	A stock-first portfolio, not this page’s crypto source list.	BTC xPub; EVM ETH / Arbitrum / BSC; Solana; Binance + Bybit RO API, spot only; Hyperliquid by address.
Bank / cash / property	See their product. Not quoted here.	Yodlee US-only.	Manual only. No Plaid.
PnL / reports	Paid plans can include tax reports. Free does not.	Equities and dividends.	Zero-crossing / current-position PnL. Bitcoin xPub strongest full-history. No tax.
Headline price	Free: 1 portfolio / 10 holdings. Starter $7 USD/mo billed annually ($9.33 monthly). Standard $18 / $24. Premium $23.25 / $31. Business $13.50 per portfolio/month.	Bronze $95.40/yr. Silver $239.40/yr. Gold $479.40/yr. Yearly toggle $7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95.	3 free, then $1/mo or $10/yr.
What it is not	Not a broker.	Not a broker-dealer.	Not a Sharesight or Yahoo replacement. No MCP. Not local-only.
Best fit	Equities, dividends, tax reports.	Equities and a US-only Yodlee link.	Crypto PnL companion. Not a stock tracker.

Sharesight prices and the Free tax-report limit are from Sharesight pricing as of 2026-08-26. Yahoo plan dollars are from Yahoo’s official plans as of 2026-08-26. Recheck those products — plans move. This page does not publish a live Sharesight or Yahoo URL.

Choose Sharesight if

Choose Sharesight if most of these are true:

• You want a stock-first portfolio tracker with dividends and tax reports.
• Free (1 portfolio / 10 holdings) is enough to try, and you accept that Free has no tax reports.
• You will pay Starter $7 USD/mo billed annually ($9.33 monthly), Standard $18 / $24, Premium $23.25 / $31, or Business $13.50 per portfolio/month.
• Crypto, if you add it, can live as file / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers. You do not need an xPub.
• You want a tracker, not a broker.

If that is the job, use Sharesight. Watchlist will not grow stock sync to win this page.

Choose Yahoo if

Choose Yahoo if most of these are true:

• You already live in Yahoo’s market / portfolio surface.
• Bronze $95.40/yr, Silver $239.40/yr, or Gold $479.40/yr (yearly toggle $7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95) is the price you expected.
• A Yodlee link that is US-only is enough.
• You want a market product that is not a broker-dealer.

If that is the job, use Yahoo. Watchlist is not a Yahoo clone.

Choose Watchlist if

Choose FinCobra Watchlist if most of these are true:

• You will live on the shipped crypto sources only: Bitcoin xPub; EVM on Ethereum, Arbitrum, and BSC; Solana; Binance and Bybit read-only API, spot only; Hyperliquid by address.
• You want zero-crossing / current-position PnL, with Bitcoin xPub as the strongest full-history source. Details: Watchlist docs.
• You will enter bank, cash, and property by hand. No Plaid.
• 3 free, then $1/mo or $10/yr, is the price you want.
• You will sign in with Google or a wallet, on the SPA/PWA. Not local-only. No MCP.
• You will keep Sharesight or Yahoo for stocks. Watchlist does not sync stocks or ETFs and does not do tax.

“Portfolio tracker crypto vs stocks” here means companion. Not “Sharesight with a $10 sticker.”

Where Sharesight and Yahoo win, without the dodge

Equities and dividends. That is their book. Watchlist has no stocks/ETFs sync.

Tax reports. Sharesight’s Free plan has no tax reports. Paid Sharesight is the tax-report product on this page. Watchlist has no tax.

Stock-first catalog. Sharesight and Yahoo are built for brokerages and listed holdings. Watchlist ships the short crypto list above. We will not invent a brokerage sync.

If you need those, stop. Keep Sharesight or Yahoo.

What Watchlist actually is

Watchlist is the SPA/PWA. Sign up with Google or a wallet. It is not local-only. There is no MCP. Docs.

Shipped crypto sources:

• Bitcoin xPub
• EVM: Ethereum, Arbitrum, BSC
• Solana
• Binance read-only API, spot only
• Bybit read-only API, spot only
• Hyperliquid by address

PnL is zero-crossing / current-position. Bitcoin xPub is the strongest full-history source.

Bank, cash, and property are manual. No Plaid.

Price: 3 free, then $1/mo or $10/yr.

It is not a Sharesight or Yahoo replacement. No stocks/ETFs sync. No tax.

Price, honestly

Sharesight (2026-08-26): Free 1 portfolio / 10 holdings, and Free has no tax reports. Starter $7 USD/mo billed annually ($9.33 monthly). Standard $18 / $24. Premium $23.25 / $31. Business $13.50 per portfolio/month.

Yahoo official plans (2026-08-26): Bronze $95.40/yr, Silver $239.40/yr, Gold $479.40/yr. Yearly toggle $7.95 / $19.95 / $39.95.

Watchlist: 3 free, then $1/mo or $10/yr.

$10/yr vs Sharesight Starter or Yahoo Bronze is only a comparison if you already accepted no stock sync and no tax. If you still need equities, dividends, or tax reports, you are comparing a stock tracker to a crypto companion that cannot replace it.

What crypto-vs-stocks pages usually skip

Most portfolio tracker crypto vs stocks results flatten one app into both jobs. That is the wrong set if you still want a brokerage book.

Four skips:

1. “Watchlist replaces Sharesight or Yahoo.” It does not. They win equities, dividends, and tax reports. We are a companion / subset.
2. “They both do crypto the same way.” Sharesight crypto is file / CSV / manual CRYPTO tickers, no xPub. Watchlist sells zero-crossing / current-position PnL, with Bitcoin xPub as the strongest full-history source.
3. “$1/mo vs $7 or $7.95.” True as arithmetic. False as a product comparison unless you already dropped stocks and tax.
4. A cheaper stock tracker. Watchlist has no stocks/ETFs sync. The price is lower because the job is smaller.

How to decide in one pass

1. Need equities, dividends, or tax reports? → Sharesight or Yahoo. Watchlist has no stocks/ETFs sync and no tax. Stop.
2. Need Sharesight’s paid tax reports, or Yahoo’s US-only Yodlee link? → Those products. Stop.
3. Need a broker or broker-dealer? → Neither Sharesight, Yahoo, nor Watchlist. Stop.
4. Need zero-crossing / current-position PnL on the listed crypto sources, manual bank/cash/property, 3 free then $1/mo or $10/yr, while Sharesight or Yahoo keeps the stock book? → FinCobra Watchlist.

Open Watchlist

If step 4 is the job, open watch.fincobra.com.

Do not ask us to be Sharesight or Yahoo. They keep stocks. This product tracks crypto PnL.